QR6.3.2 Orchestrating Coherence

Molecules vibrating in exact synchrony maintain a coherence that is usually lost in the molecular bustle of a normal cell. The timing of the synchrony must be almost perfect to produce this quantum effect, so how do photosynthetic bacteria do it?

One theory is that the microtubule cell structure orchestrates it (Penrose & Hameroff, 2017). Microtubules are self-assembling polymers that appeared over a billion years ago and are the skeleton of all cells today. They affect shape, growth, and function. Coherence plays a role in enzyme activity (Frohlich, 1970), and microtubules allow synchronous oscillations that give strong Frohlich coherence at room temperatures (Samsonovich et al., 1992).

If the cell structure oscillates synchronously, molecules in it will do the same, allowing them to superpose, cohere and entangle to act as one. That microtubules can apply quantum effects at cell timescales has led to their study in biological puzzles like smell, protein folding, ion channels, and bird navigation (Gauger, 2011). 

Orchestrated coherence theory (Orch OR) argues that brain microtubules unify the brain to make it a quantum computer that processes information in a way that classical processing can’t (Penrose & Hameroff, 2017). Critics note that while microtubules enable coherence at cell timescales, the time scale of human consciousness is orders of magnitude greater (Jedlicka, 2017). Microtubules also don’t explain why some brain events are conscious and others aren’t (Baars & Edelmann, 2012). Comatose brains have as many microtubules as normal ones, so why aren’t they conscious? About half the human brain doesn’t support consciousness directly but nerves in these regions contain just as many microtubules.

   Penrose and Hameroff make a good case for consciousness at the cell scale based on a tubulin decoherence time of 10-13 seconds (Tegmark, 2000) but even their 10-6 seconds best estimate is too brief for human consciousness (Penrose & Hameroff, 2017) p27. Tubulin-based entanglement may enable cell consciousness but it isn’t enough for human consciousness.